Psychology is full of findings that grew in the retelling. A study with 40 people becomes “science proves”, a contested theory becomes common knowledge, and a quote gets attached to someone who never said it. These are the rules we follow so that we don’t add to the pile.
1. We start from the original
We read the original study or document wherever it can be accessed: the paper, the monograph, the archive. Textbooks, encyclopaedias and news articles help us find our way, but we don’t rely on them for the facts on a page. When we can only reach a source through someone else’s summary, we say so in the source list.
2. Every page lists its sources
At the end of each page you’ll find the sources we used, with links or DOIs wherever they exist. If a claim on the page isn’t supported by something on that list, that’s a mistake, and we want to hear about it.
3. Every claim is checked by someone else
Before a page is published, a separate review step, independent of the writing, goes through every factual claim (numbers, dates, names, quotations, descriptions of methods) and checks each one against the sources. Anything that can’t be confirmed is either removed, reworded to match what the evidence supports, or clearly marked as uncertain.
4. Facts are facts, theories are theories
When something is well documented, we state it plainly. When something is still debated, we present it as a debate: what the claim is, who supports it, who disputes it, and on what grounds. We try not to pick a side unless the evidence does.
5. We follow the story after publication
A famous result is only the beginning. For every experiment we look for what came next: replications, failed replications, meta-analyses, archival investigations and critiques. A finding that has weakened over time is reported as weakened, even if the original version is more exciting.
6. Quotations are short and real
We quote sparingly and briefly, and only from a source we can name. Psychology is full of famous lines that were never said. If we can’t trace a quotation to where it first appeared, we don’t use it.
7. Images have clear licences
We only use images that are in the public domain, released under an open licence, or drawn by us. Each image shows its author, title, source and licence. Our own illustrations are original and don’t imitate existing characters or artworks.
8. We are not your therapist
We explain research. We don’t diagnose, treat or give personal psychological advice, and our tests are for self-reflection, not clinical assessment. See our disclaimer.
9. Corrections
If we get something wrong, we fix it and note the correction on the page. Write to contact@thesubtextofus.com with the page and what you believe is wrong. A link to a source helps us check it quickly.
10. Independence
What we write is not for sale. If we ever publish sponsored content or affiliate links, they will be clearly labelled as such, and sponsors will have no say over what our pages conclude.