The big ideas
Complexes
HistoricalClusters of emotionally charged memories and ideas that can disturb our thinking and behaviour; Jung first traced them through delays and odd responses in word association tests.
The collective unconscious
ContestedBeneath each person's own forgotten or repressed material lies a deeper layer of the mind that Jung believed is inherited and common to all humanity.
Archetypes
ContestedInborn patterns within the collective unconscious, such as the mother or the wise old man, which Jung thought shape the images that recur in myths, dreams and religious symbols.
Introversion and extraversion
Mixed evidenceTwo basic attitudes: the extravert's energy turns towards the outer world, the introvert's towards the inner world of thoughts and impressions.
Psychological types
ContestedCombining the two attitudes with four functions (thinking, feeling, sensation, intuition) gives eight types, set out in Psychological Types (1921).
In brief
Carl Gustav Jung was a Swiss psychiatrist who founded his own school, analytical psychology, after a famous break with Sigmund Freud. He grew up the son of a Swiss Reformed pastor, studied medicine in Basel and in 1900 joined the Burghölzli, the psychiatric hospital in Zurich then run by Eugen Bleuler. There he worked with the word association test and, still in his early thirties, became one of the best-known young names in European psychiatry.
In 1906 he began writing to Freud, and the two met in Vienna in 1907. Freud came to see Jung as his likely successor, and in 1910 Jung became the first president of the International Psychoanalytical Association. Within a few years their disagreements had ended the friendship. Jung then went through a long period of inner turmoil and self-exploration, from 1913 until around the end of the First World War, which shaped the rest of his work.
He went on to write about personality types, religion, myth and alchemy, travelled in North America, Africa and Asia, held professorships in Zurich and Basel, and saw an institute in his name founded in Zurich in 1948. He died at his home in Küsnacht in 1961. His record in the 1930s remains the subject of a real historical debate, set out below.
The big ideas
Complexes. In word association tests, a person hears a list of words and answers each with the first word that comes to mind. Jung noticed that some words produced long pauses, strange answers or signs of emotion. He took these as traces of complexes: clusters of feeling-laden memories and ideas that act somewhat independently of our conscious intentions. The word has entered everyday language.
A broader libido. Freud saw sexuality as the main force behind mental life and neurosis. Jung came to treat libido as psychic energy in general, and he paid more attention to a patient’s present problems than to childhood conflicts. His book on the transformations of libido, published in two parts in 1911 and 1912, made the difference public.
The collective unconscious and archetypes. Jung’s most distinctive idea is that the unconscious has two layers. The personal unconscious holds each person’s own forgotten and repressed material. Beneath it, he proposed, lies a collective unconscious that all humans inherit. It contains archetypes: inborn patterns, such as the mother or the hero, that shape images which keep reappearing in myths, dreams and religious symbols across very different cultures.
Introverts and extraverts. In Psychological Types (1921), Jung described two basic attitudes. The extravert’s interest flows mainly outwards, towards people and things; the introvert’s flows inwards, towards thoughts and impressions. He combined these with four functions, thinking, feeling, sensation and intuition, giving eight types. Jung described himself as an introvert, and from 1923 he built a stone tower at Bollingen, where he spent long periods alone.
The Red Book. From 1913 Jung deliberately let fantasies and visions arise, recorded them, and later copied them into a large red book, a project he returned to until the early 1930s. Commentators see this period as the foundation of his mature theories. His heirs kept it private for decades; it was published only in 2009, in an edition prepared by Sonu Shamdasani.
What holds up, and what doesn’t
Introversion and extraversion are the part of Jung’s work that has travelled furthest into mainstream psychology. Researchers still find the distinction useful, and extraversion is a core dimension in today’s trait models of personality. But modern research generally measures it as a scale on which most people fall somewhere in the middle, not as two separate kinds of people, and it defines the trait differently from Jung.
The eight types, and the MBTI built on them, are contested. Defenders, including many practitioners in workplaces and churches, value them as a vocabulary for differences in preference. Critics in academic psychology reply that, of the MBTI’s four scales, only introversion–extraversion holds up well, that the types do not predict career or other specific outcomes, and that the descriptions are vague enough to fit almost anyone.
The collective unconscious and archetypes are the most disputed ideas. Critics make several objections: there is no clear way to test whether archetypes exist or to show that they are inherited rather than learned through culture; the idea of inherited images resembles discredited Lamarckian views of evolution; and the same objection applies, more strongly, to Jung’s later notion of synchronicity, meaningful coincidences without a causal link. Freud’s followers accused him of mysticism from early on, and later writers such as Erich Fromm and Philip Rieff portrayed his psychology as a kind of private religion. In The Jung Cult (1994) the writer Richard Noll went further, portraying Jung as a would-be charismatic leader. Jungian analysts, represented today by the International Association for Analytical Psychology, and post-Jungian writers such as Andrew Samuels reply that Jung’s ideas are best judged as a clinical and interpretive framework rather than as laboratory hypotheses, and they have revised many of his claims.
The 1930s. In 1930 Jung became honorary president of the German medical society for psychotherapy. After the Nazis took power in 1933, he took over its presidency from Ernst Kretschmer, and in 1934 it was reorganised as an international society based in Zurich. He also edited its journal, the Zentralblatt für Psychotherapie. The German group was led by Matthias Göring, a cousin of Hermann Göring, who succeeded Jung as president in 1940.
The record is uncomfortable and historians read it differently:
- The Jungian professional body itself states that between 1933 and about 1936 Jung made statements and gave talks in Germany with an anti-Semitic thrust. The best-known example is a 1934 article on the state of psychotherapy in which he contrasted “Jewish” and “Aryan” psychology to the disadvantage of the former; he later dismissed the article as nonsense in a private letter. In December 1933 the society’s journal also carried a pro-Nazi editorial, which Jung and his colleague C. A. Meier said Göring had inserted without their permission.
- Jungian authors such as Thomas Kirsch stress that the international structure allowed Jewish doctors excluded from German groups to keep their membership, and say there is no definitive evidence that he was a Nazi sympathiser. The psychiatrist Michael Fordham noted that Jung was attacked from both sides and was put on a Nazi blacklist.
- Critics point out that he never publicly opposed Nazi antisemitism, and that his 1936 essay Wotan, which explained the movement through an ancient Germanic archetype, tended to excuse individual responsibility. Writers sympathetic to Freud have called him a fellow traveller of the Nazis.
- By the mid-1930s he had turned against any association with the regime. During the Second World War he provided psychological assessments of Nazi leaders for Allen Dulles of American intelligence. After the war he privately admitted to the rabbi Leo Baeck that he had made a mistake, but, as the Jungian analyst Aryeh Maidenbaum points out, he never expressed clear regret in public.
- Historians’ verdicts vary in emphasis. Deirdre Bair, in Jung: A Biography (2003), rejects the picture of an active collaborator and attributes his conduct mainly to poor judgment and political naivety. Sonu Shamdasani regards Geoffrey Cocks’s study of psychotherapy in Nazi Germany (1985) as the best-documented account of Jung’s dealings with German psychotherapy in those years.
The weight of the evidence supports neither the picture of a committed Nazi nor that of a man with nothing to answer for.
The myth
Many people assume Jung designed the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI). He did not. The MBTI was developed later in the United States by Isabel Briggs Myers. Her mother, Katharine Cook Briggs, had begun building her own system of types after Jung’s book appeared in English in 1923, and Myers turned that interest into a questionnaire. Writers such as David Keirsey and Marilyn Bates later spread the four-letter types further.
The test borrows Jung’s attitudes and functions but changes the scheme. It turns judging versus perceiving into a fourth scale of its own (Jung used “judging” and “perceiving” only to group his functions), and it sorts people into 16 types; Jung described eight. Jung’s book was a theoretical and clinical work, not a questionnaire.
Connections
Jung learned psychiatry from Eugen Bleuler at the Burghölzli, studied in Paris with Pierre Janet in 1902–1903, and spent his most formative years in dialogue with Sigmund Freud. Like Alfred Adler, he left Freud’s circle and founded a school of his own. His influence runs in several directions: to Isabel Briggs Myers and Katharine Cook Briggs through the MBTI; to the physicist Wolfgang Pauli, with whom he published a joint volume in 1952 that set out Jung’s idea of synchronicity; and to post-Jungian analysts such as Andrew Samuels.
There is no experiment page linked to Jung yet. His word association research predates the controlled experiments covered in the Experiments section.
Why it matters today
Anyone who calls themselves an introvert or talks about a “complex” is using vocabulary Jung coined or popularised. That reach is a good reason to know what he actually claimed and what the evidence supports.
The practical lesson is to keep the parts apart. The introversion–extraversion dimension is well established in personality research, in a modified form. Personality types, archetypes and the collective unconscious are interpretive ideas that many people find meaningful, but they are theories, not findings, and since type tests do not predict career or other specific outcomes, they are a poor basis for decisions about hiring or relationships. His life also shows that influential thinkers can be original and badly mistaken at once, and that both deserve an honest hearing.
Influence map
Learned from
- Eugen Bleuler
- Pierre Janet
- Sigmund Freud
Influenced
- Isabel Briggs Myers
- Katharine Cook Briggs
- Wolfgang Pauli
- Andrew Samuels
Related: Sigmund Freud · Alfred Adler
Questions people ask
What is Jung's collective unconscious?
It is Jung's term for a deep layer of the mind that he believed all humans inherit, as distinct from the personal unconscious, which holds an individual's own forgotten or repressed experiences. In his view it contains archetypes, inborn patterns that shape recurring images in myths, dreams and religions. It is a theory, not an established finding: critics say it cannot be tested.
Why did Jung and Freud fall out?
Their disagreement was partly theoretical and partly personal. Jung rejected Freud's view that sexuality is the main driving force of the mind and the main root of neurosis, and he took religion and myth more seriously than Freud did. His book on the transformations of libido, which appeared in two parts in 1911 and 1912, made the gap public. In January 1913 Freud proposed ending their personal relationship. In April 1914 Jung gave up the presidency of the International Psychoanalytical Association, and the Zurich group left it that July.
Did Jung invent the Myers-Briggs test (MBTI)?
No. The MBTI is based on his Psychological Types (1921), but it was built by Isabel Briggs Myers, drawing on work begun by her mother, Katharine Cook Briggs. It uses four pairs of preferences and 16 types; Jung's scheme has two attitudes, four functions and eight types.
Was Jung a Nazi sympathiser?
Historians disagree. From 1933 he led an international medical society for psychotherapy whose German branch was run by Matthias Göring, a cousin of Hermann Göring, and the Jungian professional body itself acknowledges that some of his statements in Germany in 1933–36 had an anti-Semitic thrust. Defenders point out that he restructured the society so Jewish doctors could stay members, turned against the regime by the mid-1930s and was blacklisted by the Nazis. Critics note that he never spoke out publicly against Nazi antisemitism. His biographer Deirdre Bair rejects the charge that he collaborated and puts his failings down mainly to poor judgment and political naivety.
Sources
- Britannica Student Encyclopedia. Jung, Carl. kids.britannica.com/students/article/Carl-Jung/275196
- International Association for Analytical Psychology. Carl Gustav Jung. iaap.org/jung-analytical-psychology/carl-gustav-jung/
- Jacobi, J. Jung, Carl Gustav. In International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. Via Encyclopedia.com. www.encyclopedia.com/people/medicine/psychology-and-psychiatry-biographies/carl-gustav-jung
- Fordham, M. Jung, Carl Gustav. In Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography. Via Encyclopedia.com. www.encyclopedia.com/people/medicine/psychology-and-psychiatry-biographies/carl-gustav-jung
- Kirsch, T. Jung, Carl Gustav. In International Dictionary of Psychoanalysis. Via Encyclopedia.com. www.encyclopedia.com/people/medicine/psychology-and-psychiatry-biographies/carl-gustav-jung
- Jung, Carl Gustaf. In Psychologists and Their Theories for Students. Gale. Via Encyclopedia.com. encyclopedia.com/psychology/arts-construction-medicine-science-and-technology-magazines/jung-carl-gustaf
- Carl Gustav Jung. In Encyclopedia of World Biography. Via Encyclopedia.com. www.encyclopedia.com/history/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/carl-gustav-jung
- Doran, C. (2017). Rage and anxiety in the split between Freud and Jung. Humanities, 6(3), 53. doi:10.3390/h6030053
- Library of Congress. Freud exhibition: page from Freud's letter to Jung (1913). loc.gov/exhibits/freud/ex/131.html
- Jung, C. G. (1912). Wandlungen und Symbole der Libido. English translation: Psychology of the Unconscious. www.historyofmedicine.com/id/6454
- Jung, C. G. (1921). Psychologische Typen [Psychological Types].
- Jung, C. G. (2009). The Red Book: Liber Novus (S. Shamdasani, Ed.; M. Kyburz, J. Peck & S. Shamdasani, Trans.). New York: W. W. Norton. philemonfoundation.org/?p=4085
- Noll, R. (1994). The Jung cult.
- Myers, I. B., with Myers, P. B. (1980). Gifts differing.
- The Myers & Briggs Foundation. Myers-Briggs and Jung: our legacy. myersbriggs.org/about-us/myers-briggs-jung-legacy/
- Dewey, R. A. Jung's personality typology. In Psychology: An Introduction (online textbook, Psych Web). www.psywww.com/intropsych/ch11-personality/jungs-personality-typology.html
- Cocks, G. Allgemeine Ärztliche Gesellschaft für Psychotherapie. In International Dictionary of Psychoanalysis. Via Encyclopedia.com. www.encyclopedia.com/psychology/dictionaries-thesauruses-pictures-and-press-releases/allgemeine-arztliche-gesellschaft-fur-psychotherapie
- Shamdasani, S. Review of G. Cocks, Treating Mind and Body. Medical History, pp. 417–419. doi:10.1017/S0025727300066862
- Cocks, G. (1985). Psychotherapy in the Third Reich: The Göring Institute. New York: Oxford University Press.
- Jewish Currents. Carl Jung and the question of anti-Semitism. jewishcurrents.org/carl-jung-and-the-question-of-anti-semitism
- Bair, D. (2003). Jung: A Biography. Boston: Little, Brown. www.irishtimes.com/news/cold-prophet-of-a-new-age-1.1304602
- On the History of the Psychoanalytic Movement. In International Dictionary of Psychoanalysis. Via Encyclopedia.com. encyclopedia.com/psychology/dictionaries-thesauruses-pictures-and-press-releases/history-psychoanalytic-movement
- Jung, C. G., & Pauli, W. (1952). The Interpretation of Nature and the Psyche (English edition of their joint volume). www.routledge.com/The-Interpretation-of-Nature-and-the-Psyche-The-work-of-Carl-Jung-and-Wolfgang/Main-Jung-Pauli/p/book/9781315101606