The big ideas
A different psychology of women
HistoricalHorney argued that Freud's account of women, including penis envy, reflected a male point of view, and that many of women's difficulties came from a society that held them back rather than from anatomy.
Men's envy of motherhood ('womb envy')
ContestedIn 1926 she suggested that men may envy women's ability to bear and nurse children, and that this envy may feed the urge to devalue women.
Basic anxiety
HistoricalA child who feels isolated and helpless in a world that seems hostile develops a deep, lasting anxiety; she located its sources in relationships and culture, not in sexual drives.
Neurotic needs and the three trends
Mixed evidenceTo cope with that anxiety, people may come to rely compulsively on moving toward others (compliance), against them (aggression) or away from them (detachment).
Real self and idealised self
HistoricalNeurosis pulls a person away from their real self, the source of growth, toward a flattering idealised image enforced by rigid inner demands she called the 'tyranny of the should'.
In brief
Karen Horney was a German-born psychiatrist and psychoanalyst who spent her career arguing, from inside psychoanalysis, that Freud had got some basic things wrong. Born Karen Danielsen near Hamburg in 1885, she began medical studies at Freiburg in 1906, at a time when German universities had only just started admitting women; according to her biographers she was the only woman in her class. She qualified in Berlin and trained as an analyst with Karl Abraham, one of Freud’s closest followers. In 1920 she was the only woman among the founders of the Berlin Psychoanalytic Institute, where she taught for over a decade.
Her first dissent concerned women. From the mid-1920s she published papers questioning Freud’s account of female development. In 1932 she moved to the United States, first to the Chicago Institute for Psychoanalysis and, from 1934, to New York, where she practised, taught at the New School for Social Research and wrote the books that made her widely read.
Those books moved further from Freud, and in 1941 the New York Psychoanalytic Institute demoted her. She left and built her own institutions, which survive today. She died in New York in December 1952, having recently developed an interest in Zen Buddhism and travelled to Japan.
The big ideas
Women, seen through men’s eyes. In “The flight from womanhood” (1926) Horney argued that psychoanalysis described women from a male point of view. Freud treated a girl’s development as shaped by the discovery that she lacks a penis, and motherhood as partly a compensation for it. Horney accepted that girls might feel such envy but gave it far less weight. She saw motherhood as a source of satisfaction in its own right, and she traced many of women’s difficulties to a society that gave men privileges and kept women dependent.
Men’s envy of motherhood. In the same paper she turned the argument around: men, she suggested, may envy women’s ability to carry and nurse children, and the urge to devalue women may partly be a defence against that envy. The idea later became known as “womb envy”.
Basic anxiety. In her American books, starting with The Neurotic Personality of Our Time (1937) and New Ways in Psychoanalysis (1939), she moved away from instinct altogether. She rejected Freud’s libido theory and the death instinct. Neurosis, she argued, starts with basic anxiety: a child’s sense of being alone and helpless in a world that feels hostile, produced by how the child is treated and by the culture around the family.
Neurotic needs and three directions. People defend themselves against that anxiety with strategies that start as reasonable and become compulsive. In Self-Analysis (1942) she listed ten such “neurotic needs”, among them needs for affection and approval, for a partner who would take over one’s life, for power, for admiration and for perfection. In Our Inner Conflicts (1945) she reorganised her account around three directions: moving toward people (compliance, seeking love and approval), moving against people (aggression, seeking control and success) and moving away from people (detachment, seeking self-sufficiency). Everyone uses all three; the trouble, in her view, begins when one becomes rigid and the person can no longer choose.
The real self and the idealised self. In Neurosis and Human Growth (1950) she described the real self as an inner source of growth that, in good conditions, develops on its own. Under pressure, a person builds instead a flattering idealised image and then tries to live up to it, driven by rigid inner commands she called the “tyranny of the should”. Failing to match the image breeds self-contempt.
Self-analysis. Because she believed in that drive to grow, and because there were far too few analysts, she argued that people could do some of the work themselves. Self-Analysis offered a method, while admitting it was hard and often incomplete.
What holds up, and what doesn’t
The critique of Freud on women has largely won the argument. Penis envy has little place in mainstream psychology today, and the view that women’s lives and psychological difficulties are shaped by social conditions is now widely shared. Horney was not alone, and her own focus shifted: by the late 1930s she wrote less about women as a separate case and folded those ideas into a general theory of neurosis.
“Womb envy” remains a hypothesis. The idea is still discussed in psychoanalytic and cultural writing, but it rests on clinical interpretation, and there is no body of research testing it. It is best read as a provocative reversal of Freud, not an established finding.
Her broad direction was absorbed, her terms less so. Historians of psychoanalysis note that her focus on relationships, culture and the need for security anticipated changes that later became standard within psychoanalysis itself. She is usually grouped with Harry Stack Sullivan and Erich Fromm as a “neo-Freudian”.
Little direct testing. Like most psychoanalytic theory, her ideas came from clinical observation rather than controlled studies, and personality psychologists have done relatively little empirical work on them. One exception is a set of questionnaires developed by Frederick Coolidge and colleagues to measure the three trends; the results reported so far are preliminary. Critics in her own time also found her notion of a natural drive toward growth too vague and too optimistic to serve as a standard.
Self-analysis met scepticism. When Self-Analysis appeared, psychoanalytic journals largely ignored it, and the critic Lionel Trilling doubted that a troubled person could analyse himself. Her later books were also little reviewed in the field.
The myth
Horney is often said to have coined “womb envy”, and even sympathetic writers attach the phrase to her. The idea is hers: in 1926 she proposed that men may envy pregnancy and motherhood. But she does not appear to have used the phrase herself. It is a later label for her argument, and who first used it is unclear; by 1984 the philosopher Eva Kittay could ask, in the title of a paper, “why not womb envy?”.
Connections
Horney learned psychoanalysis from Sigmund Freud’s circle in Berlin: she was analysed by Karl Abraham and, in the 1920s, by Hanns Sachs. Her emphasis on social relationships invites comparison with Alfred Adler, who had also broken with Freud over the weight given to sexual drives.
In New York she worked closely with Clara Thompson, Erich Fromm and Harry Stack Sullivan. The 1941 break with the New York Psychoanalytic Institute followed long friction over her views and students’ requests for a broader curriculum. The Society voted to demote her from instructor to lecturer, ending her role in training analysts; the vote is reported as 24 to 7, though accounts differ on the number of abstentions. She walked out with Thompson and three other analysts, and within weeks they had formed the Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis and launched the American Journal of Psychoanalysis, followed by a training institute, the American Institute for Psychoanalysis, with Horney as dean. The new group split in 1943, when she restricted training roles to physicians and Fromm, Thompson and Sullivan left amid professional and personal rivalries. The Karen Horney Clinic opened in New York in 1955. Her ideas also travelled into literary criticism, notably through Bernard J. Paris, who wrote Horneyan readings of fiction.
Why it matters today
Horney’s three directions remain an easy way to describe how people handle conflict: by giving in, by pushing back or by pulling away. Her claim that culture shapes what counts as normal, including for women, has become common ground. Her picture of the “tyranny of the should” resembles ideas found in later therapies that target rigid demands on oneself, though any claim of direct descent would go beyond what the sources here show.
Her theories are clinical portraits, not tested laws, and they work better as questions to ask about oneself than as labels. This page is not psychological advice; persistent distress is a matter for a qualified professional.
Influence map
Learned from
- Sigmund Freud
- Karl Abraham
- Hanns Sachs
Influenced
- Bernard J. Paris
- Frederick L. Coolidge
Related: Sigmund Freud · Alfred Adler
Questions people ask
What was Karen Horney's main disagreement with Freud?
She rejected the idea that personality is driven mainly by sexual instinct, and she rejected the death instinct. She argued that anxiety and neurosis grow out of a child's relationships and the surrounding culture. On women, she argued that Freud's theory, including penis envy, looked at women through men's eyes and ignored how society limited them.
What are Horney's three trends?
In Our Inner Conflicts (1945) she described three broad ways of coping with anxiety: moving toward people (seeking affection and approval), moving against people (seeking power and control) and moving away from people (seeking independence and distance). She saw all three as normal in flexible doses; the trouble comes when one becomes rigid and compulsive.
Why was Karen Horney expelled from the New York Psychoanalytic Institute?
Many accounts say expelled, but strictly she was demoted and then walked out. In April 1941, after years of friction over her break with orthodox theory, the Institute reduced her status from instructor to lecturer, so she could no longer train analysts. She walked out with four colleagues and, within weeks, founded the Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis.
Can you really analyse yourself?
Horney thought people could make real progress on their own, partly because there were far too few analysts, though she called self-analysis difficult and often incomplete. Critics at the time, including the literary critic Lionel Trilling, doubted it. Her book Self-Analysis (1942) is a guide to reflection, not a substitute for professional help.
Sources
- Birnbach, M. Horney, Karen. In International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences (via Encyclopedia.com). www.encyclopedia.com/social-sciences/applied-and-social-sciences-magazines/horney-karen
- Encyclopedia of World Biography. Karen Danielsen Horney (via Encyclopedia.com). www.encyclopedia.com/people/medicine/psychology-and-psychiatry-biographies/karen-horney
- Gale Encyclopedia of Psychology. Horney, Karen (via Encyclopedia.com). www.encyclopedia.com/medicine/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/horney-karen
- EBSCO Research Starters. Karen Horney. ebsco.com/research-starters/history/karen-horney
- Grosskurth, P. (1987, 5 November). The woman who broke away [review of S. Quinn, A Mind of Her Own: The Life of Karen Horney, and K. Horney, Final Lectures]. The New York Review of Books. www.nybooks.com/articles/1987/11/05/the-woman-who-broke-away/
- Shapiro, S. A. (2002). The history of feminism and interpersonal psychoanalysis. Contemporary Psychoanalysis, 38, 213–256. internationalpsychoanalysis.net/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/The_History_of_Feminism_and_Interpersona.pdf
- Shapiro, S. A. (2017). The history of the William Alanson White Institute sixty years after Thompson. Contemporary Psychoanalysis, 53(1), 44–62. https://doi.org/10.1080/00107530.2016.1277502 internationalpsychoanalysis.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/The_History_of_the_William_Alanson_White.pdf
- Kelland, M. D. Personality theory in a cultural context, ch. 6: Karen Horney and Erich Fromm. LibreTexts (open textbook). socialsci.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Psychology/Culture_and_Community/Personality_Theory_in_a_Cultural_Context_(Kelland)/06%3A_Karen_Horney_and_Erich_Fromm/6.03%3A_Horney's_Shifting_Perspective_on_Psychodynamic_Theory
- Wikipedia. Womb envy (consulted November 2026). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Womb_envy
- Horney, K. (1926). The flight from womanhood: The masculinity-complex in women, as viewed by men and by women. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 7, 324–339. (German original: Die Flucht aus der Weiblichkeit, Internationale Zeitschrift für Psychoanalyse, 12, 360–374.) pep-web.org/search/document/IJP.007.0324A
- Horney, K. (1937). The neurotic personality of our time. New York: W. W. Norton.
- Horney, K. (1942). Self-analysis. New York: W. W. Norton.
- Horney, K. (1945). Our inner conflicts: A constructive theory of neurosis; (1950). Neurosis and human growth: The struggle toward self-realization. New York: W. W. Norton.
- Coolidge, F. L., Segal, D. L., Estey, A. J., & Neuzil, P. J. (2011). Preliminary psychometric properties of a measure of Karen Horney's tridimensional theory in children and adolescents. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 67(4), 383–390. https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.20768 doi:10.1002/jclp.20768
- Encyclopaedia Britannica. Karen Horney. www.britannica.com/biography/Karen-Horney
- Karen Horney, M.D., 1885–1952 [profile]. American Journal of Psychiatry (2001), 158(8), 1205. psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.ajp.158.8.1205
- The American Journal of Psychoanalysis (journal website). Karen Horney [biographical page]. amjpa.org/?p=233
- Kittay, E. F. (1984). Rereading Freud on 'femininity' or why not womb envy? Women's Studies International Forum, 7(5), 385–391.
- Heidelberg University. 125 years of women studying at Universität Heidelberg (news release). www.uni-heidelberg.de/en/newsroom/125-years-of-women-studying-at-universitat-heidelberg