The big ideas
Independence and conformity under group pressure
SupportedFaced with a unanimous group giving a plainly wrong answer, people often yielded, but more often stayed independent; a single ally removed most of the pressure.
Impressions are organised wholes
Mixed evidenceWe do not add up a person's traits one by one; each trait takes its meaning from the others, so one word such as 'warm' or 'cold' can change the whole picture.
Prestige changes the meaning, not just the verdict
HistoricalWhen a statement is credited to a respected or a disliked author, people may be judging a different message, not reacting blindly to a name.
People as thinking members of a group
ContestedAsch argued that social life rests on people trying to understand each other and the facts, and that psychology was wrong to treat social influence as mostly irrational.
In brief
Solomon Asch was born in Warsaw in 1907 and grew up in Poland until 1920, when his family emigrated to the United States. He studied literature and science at the City College of New York and then psychology at Columbia University, where he finished his PhD in 1932. His thesis, on whether all learning curves share the same shape, was a conventional topic chosen by his adviser. What shaped him more were seminars with the anthropologists Franz Boas and Ruth Benedict, a summer he and his wife Florence spent among Hopi children in Arizona, and, above all, meeting Max Wertheimer, one of the founders of Gestalt psychology, in New York.
He taught at Brooklyn College, then succeeded Wertheimer at the New School for Social Research after Wertheimer’s death in 1943. In 1947 he moved to Swarthmore College, where his colleagues included the Gestalt psychologist Wolfgang Köhler. He stayed about twenty years, and it was from there that he ran the group pressure experiments he is remembered for, with students from other colleges as participants. He later directed the Institute for Cognitive Studies at Rutgers (1966–1972) and taught at the University of Pennsylvania from 1972, becoming emeritus in 1979. He died in Haverford, Pennsylvania, in February 1996, at 88.
He was known for experiments that were simple in design and surprisingly deep in what they revealed. His 1952 textbook, Social Psychology, set out his view of the whole field and was reprinted by Oxford University Press in 1987.
The big ideas
Independence and conformity. Asch’s best-known experiments, first reported in 1951 and published in full in 1956, put one real participant in a room with a group who had been told to give the same wrong answer about which of three lines matched a fourth. The lines were easy to judge alone, so any error showed the pull of the group. On the critical rounds participants went along with the wrong answer a little over a third of the time; the rest of the time they reported what they saw. A single person who gave the correct answer cut the group’s influence to about a quarter. The full design and results are on the page about the Asch line experiment.
Impressions as wholes. In 1946 Asch read students a short list of traits describing an imaginary person. Two lists were identical except for one word, “warm” or “cold”. The “warm” person was judged far more generous and kind, while some traits, such as honesty, barely moved. In another study, the same six traits in reversed order gave different impressions: the first words seemed to set a direction for reading the rest. His conclusion, in Gestalt terms, was that we perceive a person as an organised structure in which each trait colours the others, not as a sum of separate items.
Prestige and meaning. Earlier researchers had found that people rate a quotation more highly when it is credited to someone they admire, and took this as proof that opinions follow prestige blindly. In 1948 Asch argued that this reading assumed the statement stayed the same. In fact, he said, knowing the author changes what the words are understood to mean: “a change in the object of judgment, rather than in the judgment of the object.”
People as thinking members of a group. Running through all of this was a view of human nature. Asch treated psychology as a natural science but rejected the reductionism of both behaviourism and Freudian theory. He argued that social life depends on people trying to grasp the facts and each other, and that relying on others is often reasonable. That is why group pressure mattered to him: in his 1955 account he wrote that “consensus, to be productive, requires that each individual contribute independently.”
What holds up, and what doesn’t
The group pressure effect is robust. A 1996 meta-analysis by Rod Bond and Peter Smith pooled 133 studies from 17 countries using Asch’s line task. Across them, the size of the effect varied: in the United States conformity declined after the 1950s, and it was higher in more collectivist countries. The finding is solid; the exact percentage is not a fixed property of human nature.
What the results mean is still debated. The standard textbook reading treats each yielding answer as evidence of conformity. Bert Hodges and Anne Geyer (2006) argue instead that participants were balancing several values at once, including truth, trust in other people and social solidarity, and that occasionally agreeing with a group need not be a failure. Asch’s own interviews fit neither story neatly: some who yielded came to doubt their own eyes, while others knew the group was wrong and went along anyway. Both readings draw on the same data.
The impression studies are mixed. A preregistered replication with more than 1,000 online participants (Nauts and colleagues, 2014) found that swapping “warm” and “cold” did shift overall impressions, but that intelligence mattered at least as much as warmth, and that how central a trait was depended on the list it appeared in. The authors concluded that Asch’s data do not support the later idea that warmth always comes first, which Asch himself had not claimed, but that they fit his Gestalt view that context determines a trait’s role.
The prestige argument is of mainly historical interest. It was an important challenge to the idea of automatic “suggestion” in its day, but we found no recent study that tests it directly in its original form.
The myth
The common story is that Asch proved most people will deny their own eyes to fit in. It usually rests on one figure: about three in four participants went along with the group at least once.
The record is more balanced. In his main series, almost two-thirds of answers stayed independent, about a quarter of participants never yielded, and only about one in twenty yielded every time. Asch titled his monograph Studies of independence and conformity, with independence first. When the psychologist Richard Griggs examined 20 popular introductory textbooks in 2015, 16 mentioned the “three in four” figure, and none mentioned that about 95% of participants also defied the group at least once. Asch did find the yielding troubling. But the picture he drew was of people under real strain who, for the most part, kept telling the truth.
Connections
Learned from. Max Wertheimer was Asch’s main intellectual influence and gave him the Gestalt idea that wholes shape the meaning of their parts. At Swarthmore he worked alongside Wolfgang Köhler, another Gestalt founder. His early contact with Franz Boas and Ruth Benedict left him with a lasting interest in culture.
Influenced. Stanley Milgram was Asch’s teaching and research assistant at Harvard in 1955, adapted his method for a doctoral study of conformity in Norway and France, and worked for him again at the Institute for Advanced Study in 1959–60. According to Milgram’s biographer Thomas Blass, Milgram regarded Asch as his most important scientific influence, and his obedience experiments grew partly out of a wish to show social pressure at work on something with higher stakes than judging lines. In 1990 former students and colleagues, among them Irvin Rock, Lee Ross and Paul Rozin, published a volume of essays in his honour, The Legacy of Solomon Asch, covering perception, memory and thinking as well as social psychology.
Why it matters today
Asch’s experiments are often used to warn about herd behaviour. His own conclusions point somewhere more useful. Groups decide well when each member reports what they actually see, and one honest dissenter makes it much easier for others to do the same.
That suggests some everyday habits, though they go beyond what Asch tested directly: collecting opinions before a discussion, so the first voices don’t set the frame; inviting disagreement openly; and remembering that being the first to speak up may give someone else the courage to agree. His impression studies carry a quieter lesson. One word in a description, or the order in which we hear things about someone, can shape our whole picture of them, so it is worth asking what a first impression rests on.
Influence map
Learned from
- Max Wertheimer
- Wolfgang Köhler
- Franz Boas
- Ruth Benedict
Influenced
Experiments on this site
- The Asch Conformity Experiment: What Really Happened
- The Milgram Obedience Experiments: What Really Happened
Related: Stanley Milgram
Questions people ask
Who was Solomon Asch?
A Polish-born American social psychologist (1907–1996) who taught at Brooklyn College, the New School, Swarthmore, Rutgers and the University of Pennsylvania. He belonged to the Gestalt tradition and is best known for his experiments on group pressure.
What is Solomon Asch best known for?
The line-judgment experiments of the 1950s, in which one real participant faced a group that unanimously gave wrong answers. He is also known for his 1946 studies of how we form impressions of other people, and for his 1952 textbook Social Psychology.
Was Stanley Milgram a student of Asch?
Milgram was Asch's teaching and research assistant at Harvard in 1955 and worked for him again at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton in 1959–60. His doctoral research adapted Asch's method, and, according to his biographer Thomas Blass, he regarded Asch as his most important scientific influence.
Did Asch think people are natural conformists?
No. He was struck by how often people stayed independent, and he warned that the conformity he did find was a cause for concern because good group decisions depend on each person reporting what they actually see and think.
Sources
- Asch, S. E. (1946). Forming impressions of personality. The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 41(3), 258–290. doi:10.1037/h0055756
- Asch, S. E. (1948). The doctrine of suggestion, prestige and imitation in social psychology. Psychological Review, 55(5), 250–276. doi:10.1037/h0057270
- Asch, S. E. (1951). Effects of group pressure upon the modification and distortion of judgments. In H. Guetzkow (Ed.), Groups, leadership and men: Research in human relations (pp. 177–190). Carnegie Press.
- Renowned psych prof emeritus dies. (1996, February 27). The Daily Pennsylvanian. www.thedp.com/article/1996/02/renowned_psych_prof_emeritus_dies
- Asch, S. E. (1955). Opinions and social pressure. Scientific American, 193(5), 31–35. doi:10.1038/scientificamerican1155-31
- Asch, S. E. (1956). Studies of independence and conformity: I. A minority of one against a unanimous majority. Psychological Monographs: General and Applied, 70(9, Whole No. 416), 1–70. doi:10.1037/h0093718
- McCauley, C. Asch, Solomon. In International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. Via Encyclopedia.com. www.encyclopedia.com/social-sciences/applied-and-social-sciences-magazines/asch-solomon
- Death of Solomon Asch. (1996, March 5). Almanac (University of Pennsylvania), 42(23). almanac.upenn.edu/archive/v42/n23/asch.html
- Blass, T. (2002, March 1). The man who shocked the world. Psychology Today. www.psychologytoday.com/us/articles/200203/the-man-who-shocked-the-world
- Rock, I. (Ed.). (1990). The legacy of Solomon Asch: Essays in cognition and social psychology. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
- Nauts, S., Langner, O., Huijsmans, I., Vonk, R., & Wigboldus, D. H. J. (2014). Forming impressions of personality: A replication and review of Asch's (1946) evidence for a primacy-of-warmth effect in impression formation. Social Psychology, 45(3), 153–163. doi:10.1027/1864-9335/a000179
- Bond, R., & Smith, P. B. (1996). Culture and conformity: A meta-analysis of studies using Asch's (1952b, 1956) line judgment task. Psychological Bulletin, 119(1), 111–137. doi:10.1037/0033-2909.119.1.111
- Griggs, R. A. (2015). The disappearance of independence in textbook coverage of Asch's social pressure experiments. Teaching of Psychology, 42(2), 137–142. doi:10.1177/0098628315569939
- Hodges, B. H., & Geyer, A. L. (2006). A nonconformist account of the Asch experiments: Values, pragmatics, and moral dilemmas. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 10(1), 2–19.