The big ideas
Habit
HistoricalRepeating an action wears paths into a plastic nervous system, so that it gets easier and needs less attention. For James, habit holds both individual character and society in place.
The stream of thought
HistoricalConsciousness is not a row of separate ideas but a continuous, personal, ever-changing flow, with resting places, quick transitions and a faint fringe of meaning around each thought.
The James–Lange theory of emotion
Mixed evidenceWe do not tremble because we are afraid; the body reacts first, and feeling those bodily changes is the emotion. Carl Lange proposed a similar idea independently.
Pragmatism
ContestedThe meaning of an idea lies in the practical difference it makes, and an idea becomes true as experience bears it out. James built on an idea of Charles Sanders Peirce.
Religious experience as a subject for psychology
HistoricalIn The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902) he studied personal religious experience, not churches, through first-hand accounts, sorting them into types such as the 'healthy-minded' and the 'sick soul'.
In brief
William James was born in New York in 1842 the eldest child of Henry James Sr.; his brother Henry became the novelist. After schooling in New York and Europe and a try at painting, he turned to science at Harvard. In 1865 he went to the Amazon with the naturalist Louis Agassiz, and in 1869 he earned a medical degree he never used.
His twenties were hard: back pain, eye strain and deep depression. Reading the French philosopher Charles Renouvier on free will in 1870 helped him out, and he resolved to begin by simply believing in it. What our beliefs do for us stayed a theme of his work.
In 1872 Harvard hired him to teach physiology. By 1875 he was teaching one of Harvard’s first psychology courses and had set up a small demonstration laboratory. In 1878 he married Alice Howe Gibbens and agreed to write a textbook; it took twelve years and became the two-volume Principles of Psychology (1890). He then moved towards philosophy and religion, with The Will to Believe (1897), The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902) and Pragmatism (1907). He retired in 1907 and died of heart failure in 1910 at his summer home in New Hampshire.
The big ideas
Habit. James started from the body. Living tissue, he argued, is plastic: soft enough to be shaped, firm enough to keep the shape. Each time an action runs through the nervous system it deepens a path, so the next time is easier and needs less attention. That frees attention, and it sets character early in life. “Habit is thus the enormous fly-wheel of society,” he wrote, the force that keeps people in their places and routines. He drew practical rules from this: start a new habit with as strong a commitment as you can, allow no exceptions until it has taken root, and act on a resolution at the first chance.
The stream of thought. Against the view of the mind as separate ideas joined together, in chapter 9 of the Principles he described thought as always personal, always changing and felt as continuous, like a river rather than a chain. Some parts of the stream are resting places, such as a clear image; others are quick passages, the felt sense of “and”, “but” or “if”. Around each thought runs what he called a fringe, a faint awareness of where it came from and where it is heading. He offered three names for the whole, thought, consciousness or subjective life, and used “stream of thought” for his chapter title.
Emotion. In an 1884 article in Mind, James turned common sense upside down. We normally think we see a bear, feel fear, and then run. James argued that the bodily reaction follows the perception directly, and that feeling those bodily changes is the emotion. In his words, “we feel sorry because we cry, angry because we strike, afraid because we tremble”. He limited the claim to emotions with a clear bodily expression and ran no experiment of his own, but he proposed a test: a person who had lost all bodily sensation but still felt strong emotion would refute him. In 1885 the Danish physiologist Carl Lange published a similar, narrower theory, and the two names have been joined ever since.
Pragmatism. James borrowed the core of pragmatism from his friend Charles Sanders Peirce and first called himself a pragmatist in a lecture at Berkeley in 1898. The method is simple to state: to understand an idea, ask what practical difference it would make if it were true. More controversially, he held that ideas become true as experience bears them out, and he treated truth as one kind of good.
Religious experience. In his Gifford Lectures in Edinburgh (1901–02), published as The Varieties of Religious Experience, James set churches and doctrines aside and studied individual experience through first-hand accounts. He contrasted the “healthy-minded”, who find the world basically good, with the “sick soul”, who feels its evil keenly, and the “twice-born”, who come through such despair. He described four marks of mystical states: they resist description, feel like knowledge, pass quickly and seem to happen to a person rather than being done. He judged beliefs by their effects on a life rather than by where they came from.
What holds up, and what doesn’t
The descriptions. James’s accounts of habit and of the stream of thought were careful descriptions built from introspection and the physiology of his time, not experiments. They are best read as acute observation and a source of questions rather than as tested findings, and the stream image later travelled into literature (see the myth below).
Emotion: still argued over. The theory drew its strongest attack from Walter Cannon and Philip Bard in the 1920s. They argued that animals cut off from feedback from their internal organs still showed emotional behaviour, that the body’s arousal looks much the same across different emotions, and that it is too slow to explain how quickly feelings arise. In 1962 Schachter and Singer argued that people label general arousal using clues from the situation, though several later attempts to repeat their study failed. Whether each emotion has its own bodily pattern is still disputed. Paul Ekman and colleagues (1983) reported differences between emotions such as anger and fear, and B. H. Friedman’s 2010 review read the evidence as supporting some specificity for basic emotions. A 2018 meta-analysis by Erika Siegel and colleagues found the opposite: bodily patterns varied widely within each emotion and did not reliably tell them apart. Friedman expected James’s idea to be neither cleanly confirmed nor refuted, favoured accounts that combine several factors, and called it a lasting force in emotion research. Maria Gendron and Lisa Feldman Barrett (2009) go further: they argue that James was misread as holding that each emotion has a fixed bodily signature, partly because his view was merged with Lange’s narrower one and partly through John Dewey, and that his account was closer to their own constructionist view. This is one reading of James among several.
Pragmatism: contested from the start. Bertrand Russell and G. E. Moore subjected James’s theory of truth to harsh criticism, and others argued that it undermines the idea of absolute truth and slides towards relativism. The Will to Believe was also widely misread as a licence to believe whatever one likes; James himself later said the essay should have been called “the right to believe”.
The myth
It is often said that James coined “stream of consciousness”. He made the image famous, but the phrase was older: Alexander Bain used it in 1855. And in the chapter that made it famous, James’s main term is “the stream of thought”; “consciousness” is one of three names he offers for the same thing. May Sinclair is believed to have been the first to apply it to a novelist’s style, in a 1918 review of Dorothy Richardson.
A related caution: many sayings travel under James’s name with no book or page attached. His main works are public domain and searchable; the quotations on this page were checked against them.
Connections
James learned from Renouvier’s philosophy of free will, from his years with Agassiz and his studies in Germany, and from the circle around Peirce in Cambridge, Massachusetts. He followed the new German experimental psychology of Wilhelm Wundt closely, and rejected Wundt’s idea that a special “feeling of innervation” accompanies every voluntary act.
His students at Harvard included G. Stanley Hall, who in 1878 received Harvard’s first doctorate in psychology under him, Mary Whiton Calkins, Edward Thorndike, W. E. B. Du Bois and Gertrude Stein. His ideas shaped John Dewey and reached philosophers such as Edmund Husserl and Ludwig Wittgenstein. Alongside his science, he took psychical research seriously: he sat on the committee that organised the American Society for Psychical Research in 1884, and from 1885 he held sittings with the medium Leonora Piper, wavering for years between telepathy and contact with the dead as explanations.
Why it matters today
James kept psychology tied to life as it is lived. His chapter on habit is a reminder that much of what we do runs on routines built by repetition, and that those routines can be changed. His maxims for doing so were advice, not tested findings, and modern habit research should be checked on its own terms. His theory of emotion keeps an important question open: how much of what we feel is the body speaking? And pragmatism offers a useful habit of mind, asking what difference a belief would actually make, even for readers who reject his theory of truth.
Influence map
Learned from
- Charles Renouvier
- Louis Agassiz
- Charles Sanders Peirce
Influenced
- John Dewey
- G. Stanley Hall
- Mary Whiton Calkins
- W. E. B. Du Bois
- Edmund Husserl
- Ludwig Wittgenstein
Related: Wilhelm Wundt
Questions people ask
What is the James–Lange theory of emotion?
It is the idea that bodily changes come first and the emotion is our feeling of them: in James's 1884 wording, we are afraid because we tremble, not the other way round. The Danish physiologist Carl Lange proposed a similar theory independently in 1885. It is still debated: reviews disagree on how distinct the bodily pattern of each emotion is, and many researchers now treat bodily feedback as one ingredient among several rather than the whole story.
Did William James found American psychology?
He was one of its founders. He taught his first psychology course at Harvard in 1875 and set up one of the first psychology laboratories in the United States, used mainly for demonstrations. His Principles of Psychology (1890) became a landmark, and his students included G. Stanley Hall, Mary Whiton Calkins and W. E. B. Du Bois.
What is pragmatism?
A philosophy associated with Charles Sanders Peirce, James and John Dewey, which judges ideas by their practical consequences. For James, an idea's truth is shown by how it works out in experience. Critics, among them Bertrand Russell and G. E. Moore, attacked this theory of truth, and others argued that it undermines the idea of absolute truth and leads towards relativism.
Are the William James quotes shared online real?
Be careful with them. Many lines circulate under his name with no book, essay or page attached, and those are hard to trust. His main works are in the public domain and searchable, so a genuine quotation can usually be found in them. On this page we quote him only where we have checked the words against his own texts.
Sources
- James, W. (1884). What is an emotion? Mind, 9, 188–205. www.yorku.ca/pclassic/James/emotion.htm
- James, W. (1890). The principles of psychology (2 vols.). Henry Holt. www.yorku.ca/pclassic/James/Principles/index.htm
- Goodman, R. (2006). William James. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2006 ed.). plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2006/entries/james
- Encyclopaedia Britannica. William James. Britannica.com. www.britannica.com/biography/William-James
- Ehrenfeld, T. How William James encourages us to believe in the possible. Britannica.com. www.britannica.com/story/how-william-james-encourages-us-to-believe-in-the-possible
- Harvard University, Department of Psychology. William James. psychology.fas.harvard.edu/people/william-james
- Wright, S. James, William. In International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. Via Encyclopedia.com. www.encyclopedia.com/social-sciences/applied-and-social-sciences-magazines/james-william-0
- Gooding-Williams, R. (2017, rev. 2023). W. E. B. Du Bois. In E. N. Zalta & U. Nodelman (Eds.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2024 ed.). plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2024/entries/dubois/
- Friedman, B. H. (2010). Feelings and the body: The Jamesian perspective on autonomic specificity of emotion. Biological Psychology, 84, 383–393. doi:10.1016/j.biopsycho.2009.10.006
- Gendron, M., & Barrett, L. F. (2009). Reconstructing the past: A century of ideas about emotion in psychology. Emotion Review, 1(4), 316–339. doi:10.1177/1754073909338877
- Siegel, E. H., Sands, M. K., Van den Noortgate, W., et al. (2018). Emotion fingerprints or emotion populations? A meta-analytic investigation of autonomic features of emotion categories. Psychological Bulletin, 144(4), 343–393. doi:10.1037/bul0000128
- Sprigge, T. L. S. (1997). James, aboutness, and his British critics. In R. A. Putnam (Ed.), The Cambridge Companion to William James (ch. 7). Cambridge University Press. www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/CBO9781139000666A011/type/BOOK_PART
- The Public Domain Review. William James on the stream of consciousness (1890). publicdomainreview.org/collection/william-james-stream-of-consciousness/
- Psi Encyclopedia (Society for Psychical Research). Leonora Piper; American Society for Psychical Research (ASPR). psi-encyclopedia.spr.ac.uk/articles/leonora-piper