1904–1990 · Susquehanna Cambridge

B. F. Skinner

How much of what we do can be explained by what happened the last times we did it?

  • behaviourism
  • experimental analysis of behaviour
  • learning

Life and work

  1. 1926Graduates from Hamilton College in English literature and tries, without success, to become a writer
  2. 1931Receives his PhD in psychology from Harvard
  3. 1938Publishes The Behavior of Organisms, while teaching at the University of Minnesota
  4. 1945Moves to Indiana University as head of psychology; describes the family's 'baby tender' in the Ladies' Home Journal
  5. 1948Publishes the novel Walden Two and the pigeon 'superstition' paper; becomes a professor at Harvard
  6. 1953After visiting his daughter's maths class, builds his first teaching machine
  7. 1957Publishes Schedules of Reinforcement (with Charles Ferster) and Verbal Behavior
  8. 1971Publishes Beyond Freedom and Dignity, which provokes wide public debate
  9. 1990Speaks at the American Psychological Association convention in Boston; dies eight days later

The big ideas

  • Operant conditioning

    Supported

    Behaviour that an animal or person emits freely becomes more or less frequent depending on what follows it. Skinner treated this as a different process from the reflexes Pavlov studied.

  • Schedules of reinforcement

    Supported

    The pattern in which rewards arrive (after a fixed or varying number of responses, or a fixed or varying amount of time) produces its own typical rhythm of behaviour.

  • Radical behaviourism, including language

    Contested

    Skinner held that all behaviour, including speech and thought, can be explained by an organism's history of consequences, without appeal to inner mental causes.

  • Programmed instruction and teaching machines

    Mixed evidence

    Learning goes best in small steps, with active answers, immediate feedback and each learner moving at their own pace.

  • A designed culture (Walden Two, Beyond Freedom and Dignity)

    Contested

    Since behaviour is shaped by the environment anyway, societies should design that environment deliberately rather than rely on ideas of freedom and personal merit.

In brief

Burrhus Frederic Skinner was born in 1904 in Susquehanna, Pennsylvania. He studied English literature at Hamilton College and spent the year after graduating trying to become a novelist. It did not work. He later concluded that he had been looking at human behaviour the wrong way, and after reading Pavlov, John B. Watson and Jacques Loeb he entered Harvard’s psychology department. He earned his PhD in 1931.

Skinner spent the rest of his career on one project: a science of behaviour built on what can be observed and measured. At Harvard, then at the University of Minnesota (where he first used pigeons), at Indiana University and, from 1948, at Harvard again, he designed apparatus that let him watch one animal’s behaviour change, moment by moment, as its consequences changed. He also wrote for the public: a utopian novel, Walden Two (1948), and a widely debated argument about society, Beyond Freedom and Dignity (1971). He received the National Medal of Science in 1968.

He was diagnosed with leukaemia in 1989. On 10 August 1990 he spoke to an overflowing ballroom at the American Psychological Association convention in Boston, and he died eight days later, on 18 August, in Cambridge, Massachusetts.

The big ideas

Behaviour is shaped by its consequences. Pavlov had shown how a signal comes to trigger a reflex. Skinner was interested in something else: actions an animal produces on its own, such as a rat pressing a lever. If food follows the press, presses become more frequent; if food stops, they slowly die away. He called this kind of behaviour “operant”, and he argued that it could not be reduced to the reflex model. His The Behavior of Organisms (1938) laid out the approach.

The tools made the science. In the operant chamber (popularly, the “Skinner box”), a pigeon pecks a lit key and a food tray briefly swings into reach. A cumulative recorder moves a pen a small step with every response, so the steepness of the line shows the rate of behaviour at a glance. This let Skinner study single animals over long sessions, rather than averaging groups.

The pattern of rewards matters. With Charles Ferster, Skinner spent years comparing “schedules of reinforcement”, published in 1957. Reward after a fixed number of responses produced fast work with a short pause after each reward. Reward after a fixed time produced a pause, then speeding up as the next reward drew near. Rewards at unpredictable times produced steady responding; rewards after an unpredictable number of responses produced high, persistent responding, which Skinner compared to gambling.

Even “superstition” might be learned. In 1948 Skinner gave hungry pigeons food every 15 seconds, whatever they did. Six of eight developed a repeated movement, and he proposed that food had accidentally strengthened whatever came just before it.

Teaching could be engineered. In November 1953, after watching his daughter’s fourth-grade maths class, Skinner built his first teaching machine. In a 1958 Science paper he set out the principles: material broken into small steps, learners writing their own answers rather than choosing one, immediate feedback, and each student moving at their own pace.

So could a society. Walden Two imagines a community run on behavioural principles. Beyond Freedom and Dignity went further: since the environment shapes behaviour anyway, he argued, it should be designed deliberately, and ideas of free will and personal credit stand in the way.

What holds up, and what doesn’t

Operant conditioning and schedules: well supported. That consequences change how often behaviour occurs, and that different schedules produce characteristic patterns, are core laboratory findings of the field Skinner founded. His methods also became a tool of pharmacological testing, a contribution his National Academy of Sciences memoir mentions.

But learning has biological limits. Keller and Marian Breland, former students of Skinner who had helped on his wartime pigeon project and then trained animals commercially with operant methods, reported in 1961 that their animals drifted back towards instinctive food-handling: a raccoon trained to drop coins into a box began rubbing them together and dipping them in and out, and a pig began rooting at them, even though this delayed its food. They argued that conditioning theory had wrongly treated every response as equally easy to train. Later, closer observations of the “superstition” procedure, by John Staddon and Virginia Simmelhag (1971) and by William Timberlake and Gary Lucas (1985), pointed the same way: most of the behaviour was ordinary food-related pigeon behaviour rather than rituals built by chance.

Radical behaviourism and language: contested. In Verbal Behavior (1957) Skinner explained speech through reinforcement histories. Noam Chomsky’s 1959 review argued that the laboratory terms lost their precision when stretched to language, so that “reinforcement has totally lost whatever objective meaning it may ever have had”, and that children pick up language too quickly, from casual exposure, for step-by-step reinforcement to explain it. Skinner’s defenders disagree: Howard Rachlin, in his memoir of Skinner for the National Academy of Sciences, argues that, seen from today, the review missed the point: it was a structuralist’s complaint about a functional account. Some behaviour analysts still build on Verbal Behavior, but its account of how language is learned remains disputed.

Teaching machines: mixed. Skinner expected programmed instruction to transform schools; it did not. A 1980 meta-analysis of computer-based college teaching found real but modest gains, which its authors described as comparable to those reported for programmed instruction. Still, his core principles (immediate feedback, active answers, self-paced mastery) will look familiar to anyone who has used learning software, although how directly it descends from his work is a matter of interpretation.

The designed society: contested. Beyond Freedom and Dignity drew sharp criticism in 1971. Albert Bandura argued that control on that scale was not possible; Carl Rogers objected that Skinner left out the inner experience of choice; Rollo May saw Skinner as a totalitarian who did not fully realise it. This is a debate about values as much as evidence, and it has not been settled.

The myth

The most persistent story about Skinner is that he raised his younger daughter, Deborah, in a “Skinner box”, and that she later suffered for it, with versions claiming psychosis, a lawsuit against her father or suicide.

The story seems to have grown from a 1945 Ladies’ Home Journal article, “Baby in a Box”, in which Skinner described the crib he and his wife Yvonne had built. It was an insulated, heated enclosure with a large safety-glass window, kept at about 86°F at first and lowered gradually. The aim, he wrote, was to let a baby sleep and play without layers of clothes and blankets, and to reduce the work of infant care. There were no levers and no rewards; Deborah was taken out to be held and to play. It was later marketed, with little success, as the “Heir Conditioner” and the “Aircrib”.

Deborah Skinner Buzan has repeatedly said the rumours are false. She became an artist living in London, remained close to her father, and publicly objected when a 2004 book by Lauren Slater repeated the stories.

Connections

Skinner built on Ivan Pavlov’s study of conditioned reflexes, which he contrasted with his own operant behaviour (see /en/experiments/pavlov-conditioning/), and on John B. Watson’s case for a psychology of observable behaviour (see /en/experiments/little-albert/). Edward Thorndike’s work on learning by consequences, the biologist Jacques Loeb and his Harvard adviser W. J. Crozier also shaped his thinking.

His collaborator Charles Ferster co-wrote the schedules research; Keller and Marian Breland took operant methods into animal training, and found their limits. His critics shaped the field too: Chomsky’s review, and Albert Bandura’s work on learning by watching others (see /en/experiments/bobo-doll/). The pigeon study itself is at /en/experiments/skinner-superstition/, and the later work on learned helplessness grew out of conditioning experiments (see /en/experiments/learned-helplessness/).

Why it matters today

Skinner’s principles are at work wherever rewards are arranged on purpose. The clearest example is contingency management in addiction treatment, where people earn vouchers or prizes for verified abstinence. A 2021 meta-analysis of 74 trials in people taking medication for opioid use disorder found medium-sized benefits for abstinence and treatment adherence by the end of treatment. At the longest follow-ups, though, based on only seven studies, the benefit had largely disappeared once rewards stopped.

His schedules also offer a useful lens on everyday life, though applying them outside the laboratory goes beyond what his experiments tested. Unpredictable rewards, he noted, keep behaviour going strongly; it is reasonable to ask whether slot machines, notifications or app streaks work in a similar way. And his larger question remains open: how much should we design the environments that shape us, and who gets to do the designing?

Influence map

Learned from

Influenced

  • Charles B. Ferster
  • Keller Breland
  • Marian Breland

Experiments on this site

Related: Ivan Pavlov · John B. Watson · Albert Bandura · Carl Rogers

Questions people ask

What is operant conditioning, in simple terms?

It is learning from consequences. When an action is followed by something the animal or person gains (a reinforcer), it tends to be repeated more often; when nothing useful follows, it gradually fades. Skinner studied this with rats pressing levers and pigeons pecking keys, recording every response automatically.

What is a 'Skinner box'?

It is the popular name for the operant chamber: a small, partly soundproofed enclosure with something to press or peck and a device that delivers food. A recorder counted each response, so the rate of behaviour could be followed in fine detail.

Did Skinner really keep his baby in a box?

His second daughter, Deborah, slept and played in an enclosed, heated crib with a large window, which he described in a 1945 magazine article. She was taken out to be held and to play. There was no lever and no reward; the stories that she was harmed by it are false, according to Deborah herself.

Is Skinner's work still used today?

Yes. Reinforcement principles underlie contingency management, in which people in addiction treatment earn rewards for verified abstinence; a 2021 meta-analysis found clear benefits by the end of treatment, though they usually faded after rewards stopped. His broader claim that behaviour needs no mental explanation is far less accepted.

Sources

  1. Encyclopaedia Britannica. B. F. Skinner. Encyclopaedia Britannica online. www.britannica.com/biography/B-F-Skinner
  2. Rachlin, H. (1995). Burrhus Frederic Skinner, March 20, 1904–August 18, 1990. In Biographical Memoirs, Vol. 67 (pp. 362–377). National Academy of Sciences / National Academies Press. www.nationalacademies.org/read/4894/chapter/19
  3. B. F. Skinner Foundation. Biographical information. Contributed by B. F. Skinner's elder daughter. www.bfskinner.org/archives/biographical-information/
  4. U.S. National Science Foundation. The President's National Medal of Science: Recipient details, B. Frederick Skinner (1968, Biology). www.nsf.gov/honorary-awards/national-medal-science/recipients/b-frederick-skinner
  5. Skinner, B. F. (1945, October). Baby in a box. Ladies' Home Journal.
  6. Skinner, B. F. (1948). 'Superstition' in the pigeon. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 38(2), 168–172. doi:10.1037/h0055873
  7. Skinner, B. F. (1957). The experimental analysis of behavior. American Scientist, 45. Reprinted in American Scientist, 100(1), 54 (2012).
  8. Skinner, B. F. (1958). Teaching machines. Science, 128(3330), 969–977. doi:10.1126/science.128.3330.969
  9. Chomsky, N. (1959). A review of B. F. Skinner's Verbal Behavior. Language, 35(1), 26–58. doi:10.2307/411334
  10. Breland, K., & Breland, M. (1961). The misbehavior of organisms. American Psychologist, 16, 681–684.
  11. Time (1971, 20 September). Behavior: Skinner's utopia: Panacea, or path to hell? time.com/archive/6843845/behavior-skinners-utopia-panacea-or-path-to-hell
  12. Snopes. Did B. F. Skinner raise his daughter in a 'Skinner box'? www.snopes.com/science/skinner.asp
  13. Bolívar, H. A., Klemperer, E. M., Coleman, S. R. M., DeSarno, M., Skelly, J. M., & Higgins, S. T. (2021). Contingency management for patients receiving medication for opioid use disorder: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Psychiatry, 78(10). doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2021.1969
  14. Kulik, J. A., Kulik, C.-L. C., & Cohen, P. A. (1980). Effectiveness of computer-based college teaching: A meta-analysis of findings. Review of Educational Research, 50(4), 525–544.