John B. Watson, Rosalie Rayner · 1919–1920

The Little Albert experiment

Can a strong emotion like fear be created in a baby by pairing something harmless with something frightening?

  • Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore; the infant lived at the Harriet Lane Home for Invalid Children
  • Contested

The question

John B. Watson, a psychologist at Johns Hopkins, argued that fear, like love, is one of the primary forces that shape personality, and that emotional troubles cannot all be traced back to sex, as Freud’s followers claimed. If fears could be learned by simple association, in the way Pavlov’s dogs learned to expect food at a signal, then many adult fears might have begun in early childhood. Watson wanted to show that such learning could happen in a human being, starting in the cradle.

So he and his assistant Rosalie Rayner asked a simple question with a hard answer: can you teach a baby to be afraid?

How it was done

The child, reported only as “Albert B.”, had lived almost from birth in a hospital setting in Baltimore, where his mother worked as a wet nurse at the Harriet Lane Home for Invalid Children. The authors describe him as healthy, large for his age (about 21 pounds at nine months) and unusually calm. They chose him partly for that calm, reasoning that they could do him “relatively little harm”.

Baseline (about 9 months). Albert was shown a white rat, a rabbit, a dog, a monkey, masks, cotton wool and burning newspaper. He reached for them and handled them, and showed no fear. A film was made of these tests.

The noise (8 months, 26 days). One experimenter stood behind him and struck a steel bar, about 1.2 metres (four feet) long, with a hammer. Albert startled, held his breath and threw up his arms; by the third strike he cried. This was the frightening stimulus the study would rely on.

Conditioning (11 months). At 11 months and 3 days, Albert was shown the white rat. As his hand touched it, the bar was struck behind his head. This happened twice. A week later there were five more pairings. After seven pairings in all, the rat on its own made him cry, turn away and crawl off quickly. Between trials he was given wooden blocks, to calm him and to check that he still played normally.

Transfer tests. Five days later the rat alone still frightened him, while the blocks did not. The researchers then showed him other objects that had never been paired with the noise: a rabbit, a dog, a sealskin coat, cotton wool, the hair of one of the experimenters and a Santa Claus mask. Most produced some degree of fear or avoidance; the cotton wool produced only a mild reaction.

Later tests. At 11 months and 20 days the reaction to the rat had weakened, so it was freshened with another pairing, and the rabbit and the dog were paired with the noise as well. In a large, well-lit lecture room with four people present, his reactions to the rat and the rabbit were weaker, though the dog still made him cry. After 31 days with no further tests, at just over a year old, Albert still reacted, though less strongly: he cried at the mask, the coat, the rabbit and the dog, and pulled away from the rat without crying.

What came out

Watson and Rayner concluded that a fear could be created in a baby by simple pairing, that it spread to things resembling the original object, and that it lasted at least a month. They believed such fears could persist for life unless removed, although they admitted this belief was not well grounded.

They also described how they would have tried to remove the fear: repeated exposure until the reaction faded, pairing the feared object with food or with soothing touch, and letting Albert copy others who handled the animals calmly.

None of this was tried. Albert left the hospital on the day of the final tests, and the authors say they knew in advance that he would be leaving.

One small detail in the paper is easy to miss. When upset, Albert put his thumb in his mouth, and while he did so the frightening objects seemed to stop affecting him. The researchers had to take his thumb out of his mouth to get the fear reaction.

What really happened (replications and critiques)

A weaker result than its reputation. The paper itself shows the limits. It is one child, observed by the people who hoped for a particular result, with no independent measurement. His reactions varied from object to object and from room to room, the fear of the rat faded within days and had to be topped up, and self-soothing could switch it off. The study was never repeated in the same form, so there is no way to know how typical Albert’s reactions were.

The textbook version. In 1979 the historian of psychology Ben Harris published “Whatever happened to Little Albert?”, an early close look at how the study had been retold. Harris and others later documented how textbooks had changed many details: the laboratory rat became a pet, other animals were named as the conditioned object, Albert became an older child, and some books said his fear had been removed, which it never was. Harris later concluded that correcting textbooks one error at a time had little effect.

Who was Albert? The first answer. In 2009 the psychologists Beck, Levinson and Irons proposed that Albert was Douglas Merritte, whose mother worked at the Harriet Lane Home and, they suspected, served as a wet nurse there. They based this on a 1920 hospital census, a birth record matching the estimated birth window, family history, and a forensic comparison of photographs that found similarities but could not confirm a match. Douglas died in 1925, at age six, of hydrocephalus. The authors called the identification strongly supported, but acknowledged that no records from the period directly name the child.

A further claim. In 2012 Fridlund and colleagues, Beck among them, went further. Using Douglas Merritte’s medical records and a review of Watson’s film by a paediatric neurologist, they argued that the child had been neurologically impaired from birth, and that Watson had probably known this and presented him as healthy. The authors themselves described the evidence for Watson’s knowledge as circumstantial.

A second answer. In 2014 Russell Powell, Nancy Digdon, Ben Harris and Christopher Smithson proposed a different child: Albert Barger, son of another wet nurse listed in the same census. His hospital file records him as “Albert Barger”, matching “Albert B.”. His recorded weight at nine months (about 22 pounds) is close to the reported 21 pounds, while Douglas Merritte weighed about 15 pounds at a similar age. Albert Barger also left the hospital at the age the paper gives for the final session. He grew up under a different surname, lived until 2007, and, according to a relative, disliked dogs and animals in general. The authors are careful to say they cannot tell whether that had anything to do with the experiment.

In a separate 2014 paper, Digdon, Powell and Harris argued that the film shows a normal infant and that the case for neurological impairment and for the alleged ethical breaches does not hold. The debate is not formally settled, but the Barger identification fits more of the details in the original report.

What happened next in the field. In 1924 Mary Cover Jones, working with Watson’s guidance, published the case of Peter, a three-year-old who was already afraid of a white rabbit. By gradually bringing the rabbit closer while Peter ate something he liked, she reduced the fear until he could touch it. It is often treated as the missing second half of the Albert study: not creating a fear, but undoing one.

Ethics

Watson and Rayner admitted feeling hesitant and a certain responsibility. They justified the study by arguing that Albert would meet frightening things anyway once he left the sheltered hospital. A modern ethics board would reject this reasoning: the chance that harm might happen in ordinary life is no reason to cause it in a laboratory. Today a review board would expect, at the very least, informed permission from a parent free to refuse, a right to stop at any sign of distress, and no attempt to create a lasting fear.

What it means today

The core idea survived the flaws of the study. Fears can be learned by association, and they can also be unlearned. Jones’s work with Peter is an early ancestor of today’s gradual exposure methods for treating phobias.

The study also carries a lesson about science itself. A single, poorly controlled case became a classic because it told a clear story, and the story grew cleaner with every retelling. A few habits follow from this, though they go beyond anything Watson and Rayner tested:

Would you have passed?

Coming soon. This one is not about whether you would have been conditioned. You are the ethics board. You will read short descriptions of what Watson and Rayner planned, step by step, and decide at each point whether you would approve it, ask for changes or stop it. At the end you will see where a modern review would draw the line.

Questions people ask

What happened in the Little Albert experiment?

In 1919–1920, John B. Watson and Rosalie Rayner showed an 11-month-old boy a white rat and, as he touched it, struck a steel bar with a hammer behind his head. After seven such pairings, the rat alone made him cry and crawl away. He later reacted fearfully to a rabbit, a dog, a fur coat and a Santa Claus mask.

Was Little Albert ever cured of his fear?

No. Watson and Rayner described several methods they hoped to try, but Albert left the hospital on the day of the last tests, and no attempt to remove the fear was made. Reports that he was 'deconditioned' are a later textbook error.

Who was Little Albert really?

It is disputed. In 2009 Beck, Levinson and Irons proposed Douglas Merritte, a boy who died at age six. In 2014 Russell Powell and colleagues argued that a better match is Albert Barger, who lived until 2007. The case for Barger fits the name, weight and dates in the original report more closely, but no record directly names the child in the film.

Was the Little Albert experiment ethical?

By today's standards, no. A baby was frightened on purpose, the paper does not mention asking his mother for permission, and the fear was never undone. Watson and Rayner admitted hesitating, but argued he would meet such fears anyway once he left the sheltered hospital.

Sources

  1. Watson, J. B., & Rayner, R. (1920). Conditioned emotional reactions. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 3(1), 1–14. doi:10.1037/h0069608
  2. Beck, H. P., Levinson, S., & Irons, G. (2009). Finding Little Albert: A journey to John B. Watson's infant laboratory. American Psychologist, 64(7), 605–614. doi:10.1037/a0017234
  3. Fridlund, A. J., Beck, H. P., Goldie, W. D., & Irons, G. (2012). Little Albert: A neurologically impaired child. History of Psychology, 15(4), 302–327. doi:10.1037/a0026720
  4. Powell, R. A., Digdon, N., Harris, B., & Smithson, C. (2014). Correcting the record on Watson, Rayner, and Little Albert: Albert Barger as 'psychology's lost boy'. American Psychologist, 69(6), 600–611. doi:10.1037/a0036854
  5. Digdon, N., Powell, R. A., & Harris, B. (2014). Little Albert's alleged neurological impairment: Watson, Rayner, and historical revision. History of Psychology, 17(4), 312–324. doi:10.1037/a0037325
  6. Harris, B. (1979). Whatever happened to Little Albert? American Psychologist, 34(2), 151–160. doi:10.1037/0003-066X.34.2.151
  7. Harris, B. (2011). Letting go of Little Albert: Disciplinary memory, history, and the uses of myth. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 47(1), 1–17. doi:10.1002/jhbs.20470
  8. Jones, M. C. (1924). A laboratory study of fear: The case of Peter. Pedagogical Seminary, 31, 308–315.