The question
By the 1940s, B. F. Skinner had spent years showing that animals repeat actions that are followed by a reward. A rat presses a lever, food drops, and the rat presses more. In those experiments the reward depended on the action. Skinner asked what would happen if it did not.
Suppose food simply arrived on a clock, whatever the animal happened to be doing. If reward strengthens whatever comes just before it, then the animal’s chance movements should be strengthened too, even though they cause nothing. The animal would end up behaving, in Skinner’s words, as if its actions mattered: “The bird behaves as if there were a causal relation” between what it does and the food, though none exists. He called this “superstition”, and he put the word in quotation marks.
How it was done
Skinner used eight pigeons. Each was kept hungry in a steady way, at 75% of its well-fed body weight, so that food would reliably work as a reward.
Each bird was placed for a few minutes a day in a small experimental cage. A food hopper could swing into reach, stay there for five seconds, and then swing away. A clock controlled the hopper. In the main procedure, food came every 15 seconds. Nothing the bird did made it arrive sooner, later or more often.
For one bird, Skinner also wired up a recorder that counted its movements over many hours.
He then tried variations: a longer interval between feedings, and periods when the clock was switched off altogether, so that no food came at all.
What came out
In six of the eight birds, a clear and repeated movement appeared. Each bird had its own:
- One turned counter-clockwise around the cage, two or three times between feedings.
- One kept pushing its head into one of the upper corners.
- One kept jerking its head upward, as though pushing something unseen out of the way.
- Two swayed their head and body from side to side, like a pendulum.
- One kept dipping its head towards the floor in pecking or sweeping motions that stopped just short of it.
In the other two birds, no clear pattern formed. Most of the movements were made in one spot in the cage and pointed at some feature of it. Typically a bird repeated its movement five or six times before the next feeding.
Timing mattered. A 15-second interval worked well; a one-minute interval worked much less well. Skinner’s reasoning was that the longer a bird waits, the more its behaviour wanders, so the food is less likely to land on the same movement twice. Once a movement was established, though, the interval could be stretched. One bird kept its habit going with food every two minutes.
The habits also changed over time. One bird on a one-minute interval started with a small head movement to the left. Over many hours this grew stronger, the body began to turn with it, and it became a hop from the right foot to the left. Its recorded behaviour showed a pause after each meal, then hopping that began about 10 to 20 seconds later and continued until the next one.
When Skinner switched the food off, this bird hopped more than 10,000 times before the habit faded almost completely. When the clock was restarted, the hopping gradually came back. After a second round of no food and then food again, the bird took up a different habit, walking a set route around the cage, and the hop never returned.
Skinner then compared the birds to people. Card players have rituals to change their luck, and a bowler may keep twisting his arm and shoulder after the ball has left his hand. In his view, a ritual needs to coincide with luck only now and then to survive long runs where it achieves nothing.
What really happened (replications and critiques)
Skinner’s paper is short, and his account was a hypothesis. The paper is five pages long. It describes the birds’ habits in words and gives a mechanical record for only one bird, not a moment-by-moment record of what each bird did before each feeding. The idea that each habit was built by food accidentally following it, which later writers called “adventitious reinforcement”, is Skinner’s explanation of what he saw, not something the paper directly measured.
Staddon and Simmelhag (1971): two kinds of behaviour, not random rituals. John Staddon and Virginia Simmelhag repeated the procedure with six pigeons in all (four per condition), with food every 12 seconds (and in other conditions at irregular times, or only after a key peck). This time an observer scored each bird’s behaviour second by second with push buttons, while timing equipment recorded when each activity happened. They found a regular structure:
- Interim behaviours came early in the interval, just after food: turning, flapping the wings, pecking at the floor, moving along the wall. These varied from bird to bird.
- A terminal behaviour came late, as food drew near. For the birds that developed one, it was the same: pecking at or near the wall with the feeder, whether or not pecking had any effect.
Crucially, the behaviour that came just before food was not always the one that lasted. In at least one bird, a movement that often came right before feeding was later replaced by pecking. Staddon and Simmelhag concluded that accidental reward could not explain the pattern. They proposed that the late pecking is food-related behaviour that the approaching meal brings out, and that the early behaviours resemble the “filler” activities animals show while waiting for something.
Timberlake and Lucas (1985): mostly food-seeking. William Timberlake and Gary Lucas ran a series of experiments, usually with four pigeons and food every 15 seconds. Their birds mainly stayed near the feeder wall, stepping from side to side, bumping it with their chests, scratching and bobbing their heads. Pecking near the feeder was rarer than Staddon and Simmelhag had found. There were small individual styles, which they noted matched some of Skinner’s descriptions. But overall, behaviour was similar from bird to bird and organised around the feeder, not the scattered, one-off rituals that chance reward would predict. They concluded that timed food mainly triggers the ordinary feeding behaviour of the species.
So who is right? Researchers still debate the details, including why the two later studies saw different amounts of pecking. What is widely accepted is narrower than the textbook story: pigeons fed on a timer do develop repeated, patterned behaviour, but much of it is food-seeking that appears with or without lucky timing. Whether chance reward adds anything on top, and how much, remains an open question.
In humans. In 1987 Koichi Ono gave 20 university students points on a counter, each marked by a red lamp and a short buzzer, on a timer that did not depend on what they did. Their booth had three levers and coloured signal lights, but they were not asked to do anything in particular. According to summaries of the study, three of the twenty developed a lasting superstitious pattern: one made a few short lever pulls followed by a long one, one touched many objects in the booth, and one responded as if certain signals mattered. Most students did not develop anything stable. A later study by Lee (1996), with six students, found that three of the six kept making unnecessary cursor movements. A 2018 study in Brazil by Benvenuti and colleagues found that people who watched someone else behaving “superstitiously” tended to keep it up, which suggests that, in humans, copying others may sustain rituals that chance alone would not.
Ethics
There was no deception and no pain in the procedure as described. The cost to the birds was hunger: they were kept at 75% of their well-fed weight so that food would work as a reward. One bird spent many hours in the apparatus during the longer recordings.
Today a study like this would go before an animal-care committee, which would look closely at how much and for how long the birds’ food was restricted.
What it means today
The pigeon study is often used to explain lucky socks, pre-game routines and “my” slot machine. That comparison was Skinner’s own, and it is still useful, but the later research suggests a more careful version.
First, chance pairings may help keep a ritual alive, but they are not the whole story. In pigeons, much of the “superstition” turned out to be what hungry pigeons do anyway when food is near. In people, Ono’s students mostly did not become superstitious, and social copying seems to play a part.
Some practical thoughts follow, though they go beyond what these studies tested:
- When something good happens after you do something, it is worth asking whether it would have happened anyway.
- Rituals before an exam or a match may calm you, and that can be real help, as long as you know that the ritual itself is not moving the outcome.
- Rituals spread. If a group habit has no clear purpose, it may have been learned from others rather than from evidence.
Would you have passed?
Coming soon. Points appear on your screen at intervals while you click, wait or move the cursor. At the end you’ll be asked how much control you think you had, and then shown how the points were actually timed. One honest caveat: knowing in advance that the study is about superstition makes it much easier to resist than it was for Skinner’s pigeons or Ono’s students.
Questions people ask
What did Skinner's superstition experiment show?
Skinner gave hungry pigeons food every 15 seconds, whatever they were doing. Six of eight birds came to repeat a particular movement between feedings, such as turning in circles or swinging their heads. Skinner argued that food had accidentally followed these movements and strengthened them, much as lucky rituals are kept alive in people.
Why is the experiment called 'superstition'?
Because the birds behaved as though their movements produced the food, when the food was entirely on a timer. Skinner put the word in quotation marks in his title, and he compared the birds to card players and bowlers who keep up rituals that cannot affect the result.
Has the pigeon superstition experiment been replicated?
The basic observation, that timed food produces repeated behaviour, has been seen again. But Staddon and Simmelhag (1971) and Timberlake and Lucas (1985) watched more closely and found that most of it was food-related behaviour common to all the birds, clustered near the feeder, rather than random rituals shaped by chance.
Do people develop superstitions the same way?
Sometimes. In a 1987 study by Koichi Ono, students received points on a timer that did not depend on what they did. A few developed persistent patterns, such as a few short lever pulls followed by a long one, but most did not, so chance rewards alone do not reliably produce superstition in people.
Sources
- Skinner, B. F. (1948). 'Superstition' in the pigeon. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 38(2), 168–172. doi:10.1037/h0055873
- Staddon, J. E. R., & Simmelhag, V. L. (1971). The "superstition" experiment: A reexamination of its implications for the principles of adaptive behavior. Psychological Review, 78(1), 3–43. doi:10.1037/h0030305
- Timberlake, W., & Lucas, G. A. (1985). The basis of superstitious behavior: Chance contingency, stimulus substitution, or appetitive behavior? Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 44(3), 279–299.
- Ono, K. (1987). Superstitious behavior in humans. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 47(3), 261–271. doi:10.1901/jeab.1987.47-261
- Steele, K. M. (2019). Superstition experiment (Staddon and Simmelhag 1971). In J. Vonk & T. K. Shackelford (Eds.), Encyclopedia of animal cognition and behavior. Springer. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-47829-6_2081-1
- Lee, V. L. (1996). Superstitious location changes by human beings. The Psychological Record, 46(1), 71–86. doi:10.1007/BF03395164
- Benvenuti, M. F. L., Toledo, T. F. N. de, Velasco, S. M., & Duarte, F. M. (2018). Behavior and illusions: A model to study superstition in a participant replacement experiment. Psicologia: Reflexão e Crítica, 31(1), 17. doi:10.1186/s41155-018-0097-9