The question
In the parable in Luke’s Gospel, a man is beaten by robbers on the road from Jerusalem to Jericho. A priest walks past, then a Levite. A Samaritan, from a group the listeners looked down on, stops and cares for him.
John Darley, a psychologist at Princeton University, and C. Daniel Batson, then working with him at Princeton, read the story with a social psychologist’s eye. Darley had already co-authored the bystander studies of the late 1960s. Darley and Batson noticed something about the parable that sermons rarely stress: the priest and the Levite were busy, important people, probably with somewhere to be. The Samaritan, an outsider, probably was not in a rush. That was their reading, not something the text states.
They turned it into three predictions. First, that thinking about a story of helping would not, by itself, make people help more. Second, that people in a hurry would help less. Third, that people whose faith was more inward or more searching would help more.
How it was done
The participants were students at Princeton Theological Seminary. In a first session, 67 of them filled in personality questionnaires about their religious life. Analysis boiled the scales down to three ways of being religious: religion as a means to other ends, religion as an end in itself, and religion as a quest.
Later, each student came back alone for what was presented as a study of the vocational careers of seminarians. Testing took place over three days in December 1970. Two things were varied at random.
The message. Each student read a short text and was asked to give a three-to-five-minute talk on it, to be recorded in a nearby building. About half read a passage about jobs in which seminary graduates are most effective. The rest read the parable of the Good Samaritan itself.
The hurry. Just before sending the student off, the assistant said one of three things:
- Low hurry: it would be a few minutes before they were ready, but the student might as well head over.
- Intermediate hurry: the assistant in the other building was ready, so please go right over.
- High hurry: after a look at his watch, the assistant said the student was late, they had been expecting him a few minutes ago, so he should hurry.
The assistant then drew a small map to the other building. On the way, in an alley, sat a man slumped in a doorway, head down and eyes closed. As the student passed, he coughed and groaned. He was working with the researchers, and he did not know which condition anyone was in. If someone stopped, he said he had a respiratory condition, had taken his medicine and just needed to rest. If someone insisted, he let them take him inside.
The man rated each passer-by on a six-step scale, from not noticing him at all, through helping indirectly (for example by telling someone at the next building), stopping to ask, taking him inside, to refusing to leave him. In the other building, the student gave the talk and filled in a questionnaire on helping, designed partly to check whether he had noticed the man.
What came out
Of the 40 students analysed, 16 (40%) offered some kind of help.
Hurry made the biggest difference.
- 63% of students in low hurry offered help.
- 45% of those in intermediate hurry did.
- 10% of those in high hurry did.
Hurry was the only factor that reached statistical significance, both for whether people helped and for how much they helped.
The parable did not make a significant difference. Of the students on their way to talk about the Good Samaritan, 53% helped, against 29% of those preparing the talk about jobs. The authors noted that the gap pointed in the expected direction, but it was not large enough, in a study this size, to rule out chance. On several occasions, they report, a student hurrying to give the talk on the parable stepped right over the man in the doorway.
Religiosity did not predict who helped. None of the religion scores came close to predicting whether someone stopped. Among the 16 who did help, though, the type of religiosity was linked to the style of help. Students who scored high on religion as a quest tended to give less extensive help, which the authors read as more responsive to the man’s own statement that he was fine. Students high in doctrinal orthodoxy were more likely to show a fixed, persistent kind of helping, such as staying with him or insisting on taking him somewhere, whatever he said.
Afterwards, almost all hurried students said, when asked, that the man might have needed help, though many seemed not to have read the scene that way at the time. Some who did not stop, the authors wrote, looked aroused and anxious afterwards. Their reading was that these students were caught between two people who needed them: the man in the doorway and the researcher waiting for the recording. In their words: “Conflict, rather than callousness, can explain their failure to stop.”
What really happened (replications and critiques)
A very small study. The whole analysis rests on 40 people split into six conditions. The article gives only percentages, but they and the reported averages fit only one set of group sizes (our calculation): 8 students in low hurry, 22 in intermediate hurry and 10 in high hurry. A randomisation error, the authors say, put extra people into the intermediate group. So the famous “10%” is one person out of ten, and the “63%” is five out of eight. The hurry effect was significant, but numbers from groups this small are very imprecise.
“No effect” of the parable is not proven. The flip side of a small sample is that real differences can go undetected. A 24-point gap between 53% and 29% is not trivial; it simply was not reliable at this size. In 1975 Greenwald published a comment in the same journal questioning Darley and Batson’s “no-effect” conclusion about the parable. Textbooks that say the sermon “made no difference” overstate what the data can show.
The follow-up: conflict, not callousness. In 1978 Batson and five colleagues tested the authors’ own explanation. Male undergraduates were told either that their data were vital to a research project or that they were not, and half were also told they were late. On the way to another building, each passed a man slumped on a staircase, coughing and groaning. As predicted, among hurried participants, whether someone was depending on them to arrive made a significant difference to whether they stopped. In other words, hurry seems to work less by shutting off compassion and more by putting two obligations in competition. It came from the same research group, so it is not an independent replication.
How the story gets oversold. Popular retellings often say that seminarians stepped over a dying man on their way to preach about compassion. The study reports that this happened on several occasions, without a number, among 40 people. The man was not dying, and he told those who stopped that he was all right. It is also presented as proof that character does not matter. The data show something more modest: in this sample, the religion questionnaires did not predict whether people helped, but did relate to how they helped.
Later work. We did not find a large, independent, direct replication of the 1970 design. Related work has mostly tested the “message” side instead. In 2015, for example, Johnson and colleagues showed Christian undergraduates benevolent verses attributed either to the Bible or to US statesmen, or neutral quotations, and found that helping a stranger who dropped some envelopes was similar across conditions, unless she wore a hijab, in which case the neutral group helped less.
Ethics
The study depended on deception. Participants believed they were part of a careers study, and they did not know the man in the alley was working with the researchers. Realising you walked past someone who seemed ill could be uncomfortable, especially for future ministers.
Everyone was fully debriefed afterwards. If a student did not bring up the man in the alley, the researcher asked about him directly, explained the deception and why it was needed, and discussed how strongly situations can shape behaviour. The authors report that all participants seemed to understand and none showed resentment. The article does not mention consent forms or an ethics committee.
What it means today
The study is small, but its central idea is familiar: most of us have walked past someone who might have needed help because we were late or focused elsewhere.
A few practical thoughts follow, though they go beyond what Darley and Batson actually tested:
- Being in a hurry narrows what you notice. If you see something that might be a problem, it can help to pause for a second and ask yourself whether it is.
- Hurry often pits one obligation against another. Deciding in advance that a person in trouble outranks being on time makes that conflict easier to resolve.
- Good intentions and good values are not always enough by themselves. Leaving some slack in a schedule may do more for kindness than another reminder to be kind.
Would you have passed?
Coming soon. You are given a task, a deadline and a route. Along the way, something happens. At the end you’ll see what you did, next to the 63%, 45% and 10% from 1970. One honest caveat: on a screen you know it’s a test and no one is waiting for you, so the pressure is far weaker than on that December day in Princeton.
Questions people ask
What did the Good Samaritan experiment find?
Seminary students on their way to give a short talk passed a man slumped in a doorway. How much of a hurry they were in made the biggest difference: 63% offered help when they had time, 45% when told to go straight over, and 10% when told they were late.
Did preparing a talk on the Good Samaritan make students help more?
Not significantly. Students preparing the parable talk helped more often than those preparing a talk about jobs (53% against 29%), but with only 40 participants that gap could have been chance. A 1975 comment by Greenwald questioned whether the study really justified a 'no effect' conclusion.
Did seminarians really step over the victim?
The authors report that this happened on several occasions with students on their way to talk about the parable. They do not say how many. It is a vivid detail, but it describes a few people, not the typical participant.
Does being in a hurry make people selfish?
The authors did not think so. Many hurried students seem not to have registered the man as needing help until later, and others seemed torn between him and the researcher waiting for them. A 1978 follow-up found that hurry mattered most when people believed someone was depending on them to arrive.
Sources
- Darley, J. M., & Batson, C. D. (1973). "From Jerusalem to Jericho": A study of situational and dispositional variables in helping behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 27(1), 100–108. doi:10.1037/h0034449
- Batson, C. D., Cochran, P. J., Biederman, M. F., Blosser, J. L., Ryan, M. J., & Vogt, B. (1978). Failure to help when in a hurry: Callousness or conflict? Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 4(1), 97–101. doi:10.1177/014616727800400120
- Greenwald, A. (1975). Does the Good Samaritan parable increase helping? A comment on Darley and Batson's no-effect conclusion. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32(4), 578–583. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.32.4.578
- Johnson, K., Memon, R., Alladin, A., Cohen, A., & Okun, M. A. (2015). Who helps the Samaritan? The influence of religious vs. secular primes on spontaneous helping of members of religious outgroups. Journal of Cognition and Culture, 15(1–2), 217–231. doi:10.1163/15685373-12342147